Outrageous Article, “Why Black Women Are Less Physically Attractive Than Other Women”

     What the hell!  I just got an e-mail from the organization Color of Change that has me sitting here in disbelief.  I am going to pass the mail right on to you. I can’t add anything to what Color of Change is saying. They say it all well and besides, I am trying to get my blood pressure back to normal after reading about this and listening to the blogger’s article.  (I could not find it, so called a friend who had saved it on her hard drive and read it to me).  I am astonished that Psychology Today would have allowed this to be printed on their web site (or anywhere else) in the first place.  Sure they have retracted it, but have not responded to the scores of complaints.  As a woman, a citizen of the world, and as the mother of people of color, I am stunned and upset. I often read Psychology Today and many of my clinician friends advertise with them.

       Here’s the e-mail from Color of Change.  Make up your own minds, but if you feel their having allowed this blogger to publish this was as awful as I do, and many others do,  let Psychology Today know and take a stand.

        “Why Black Women Are Less Physically Attractive Than Other Women”

          Dear Iris,

Since Monday, more than 50,000 ColorOfChange members have called on Psychology Today to address it’s decision to run an article that uses false science to argue that Black women are “objectively” less attractive than women of other races. Still, they’ve remained silent.

Can you help us get to 70,000? It takes a second to add your voice to the call, demanding PT apologize and explain how this won’t happen again. Once we get to 70,000, we’ll deliver your petitions to Psychology Today’s headquarters to increase the pressure.

http://act.colorofchange.org/sign/psychtoday

Thanks and Peace,

– Rashad, James, Gabriel, William, Dani, Matt, Natasha, and the rest of the ColorOfchange.org team
   May 26th, 2011


 

These women aren’t as attractive as White, Asian, Latina or Native American women?http://act.colorofchange.org/go/827?akid=1995.229625.kMgufC&t=2That’s what Psychology Today has said. Demand that the journal apologize, explain how this happened, and ensure that it won’t happen again.http://act.colorofchange.org/go/827?akid=1995.229625.kMgufC&t=3

Dear Iris,

Nearly 20 years after a black parent documented how hard it was to hear, “Mommy, I want to be white,”1 Psychology Today reinforced the false and hurtful sentiment that Black women aren’t attractive.

Last week they published an article claiming it to be scientific fact that Black women are less beautiful than women of other races,2 penned by Satoshi Kanazawa, who is notorious for hiding behind pseudoscience to promote discredited racist and sexist ideas.3

By giving Kanazawa a platform and validating his ideas, Psychology Today dehumanized Black women and girls everywhere. After widespread public outcry, they removed the article from their website.4 But that alone won’t erase the damage they’ve done by validating these discredited ideas — the editors need to apologize, explain how this happened, and let us know that it won’t happen again. Please join us in demanding they do so immediately, and then ask your friends and family to do the same:

http://act.colorofchange.org/sign/psychtoday

Kanazawa’s article is flawed from top to bottom.5 Using a dataset from an unrelated study of teenagers, he draws the obviously false conclusion that Black women are “objectively” less attractive than women from other racial groups.

Kanazawa has a long history of hiding behind pseudo-science to express racist and sexist views. He once wrote an article asking “Are All Women Essentially Prostitutes?” and another suggesting that the US should have dropped nuclear bombs across the entire Middle East after 9/11 because it would have wiped out Muslim terrorists.6

So why does Psychology Today continue to give him a platform? Black women constantly face both subtle and explicit messages that they are valued less than women of other races —  messages that are especially damaging to Black girls. Now Psychology Today has served as launching point for yet another attack, this time in the name of science.

Almost as if to cover up the racism inherent in his piece, Kanazawa says that black men are, “if anything more attractive” than their counterparts of other races because of “greater testosterone.”7 But even here Kanazawa relies on the same pseudoscience to describe black men in familiar terms — brutish, hypermasculine, oversexed, exotic. And that’s dangerous, too.

He uses a modern-day version of the faulty logic used to dehumanize blacks as inferior for hundreds of years, from the social Darwinists and eugenicists of the 19th century to The Bell Curve just 15 years ago. Psychology Today has a responsibility not to give such false logic a stage, nor validation.

To undo the damage it’s done, Psychology Today needs to explicitly reject Kanazawa’s ideas. Please join us in demanding that their editors apologize, explain how this article was published in the first place and what they’ll do to ensure it won’t happen again in the future. It takes just a moment:

http://act.colorofchange.org/sign/psychtoday

Thanks and Peace,

– Rashad, James, Gabriel, William, Dani, Matt, Natasha, and the rest of the ColorOfchange.org team
   May 23,2011

Help support our work. ColorOfChange.org is powered by YOU — your energy and dollars. We take no money from lobbyists or large corporations that don’t share our values, and our tiny staff ensures your contributions go a long way. You can contribute here:

http://act.colorofchange.org/go/205?akid=1995.229625.kMgufC&t=7

References:

1. “Growing Up in Black and White,” Time, 5-17-1993
http://act.colorofchange.org/go/828?akid=1995.229625.kMgufC&t=9

2. “Why Are Black Women Less Physically Attractive Than Other Women?” Psychology Today, 5-15-2011
http://act.colorofchange.org/go/829?akid=1995.229625.kMgufC&t=11

3. “The Illustrious Career of a Crap Psychologist,” Jezebel
http://act.colorofchange.org/go/830?akid=1995.229625.kMgufC&t=13

4. “The Pseudoscience of “Black Women Are Less Attractive’,” ColorLines, 5-17-2011
http://act.colorofchange.org/go/831?akid=1995.229625.kMgufC&t=15

5. See note 3

6. “How to Debunk Pseudo-Science Articles about Race in Five Easy Steps,” Racialicious, 5-17-2011
http://act.colorofchange.org/go/832?akid=1995.229625.kMgufC&t=17

7. See reference 2

Photo by Angela7Dreams|Flickr

Cross-Blog Discussion: “The Fallen”, BBC Documentary

     The following is a cross post or “guest post” by my friend, Ruth Z. Deming, MGPGP.  Psychotherapist and Founder/ Director of New Directions Support Group, Inc.   My readers will recognize her as the subject of one of my recent blog posts.  I read this on her blog today and felt I wanted to share it, along with my comment to Ruth, so asked her permission.  She granted it.  Please visit her blog if you would like to read Ruth’s thoughts, poems, recipes and links.  http://ruthzdeming.blogspot.com/

     Your comments are always appreciated and I hope you will pass on any articles, poems or posts you read here to others you know, through Facebook, Twitter, or to your regular mailing list when something strikes you.

     Here is Ruth’s blog entry for today:


I simply could not stop watching the documentary “The Fallen” which I found on the website Documentary Heaven.com.

I knew nothing at all about it, except its powerful effect on me.

In this three-hour 2008 film, which you can watch here

 http://www.militaryphotos.net/forums/showthread.php?146343-The-Fallen-BBC-Documentary  every single British soldier, man or woman, killed in Iraq and Afghanistan, was honored.

We all wonder, How would I react if I were the family member of a beloved son or husband who was killed in a war.

I may be wrong, but nearly every person interviewed believes their family member died protecting freedom. What a comfort for them, unlike the Cindy Sheehans of America who lost children and are profoundly against these wars, as are most Americans.

Emails and cellphone calls are exchanged between soldiers and family members far away from the battlefields. One very loving father emailed his daughter how happy he was that at last she’d made a friend – it had been hard for her – and that he couldn’t wait to get home and give a huge hug to his wife and daughter.

It was never to be. The man killed himself. We don’t know why. This haunts me. Why? Did he despise himself for killing innocent people? Had he seen too much and felt too much and couldn’t take it anymore? His daughter, sadly, could not forgive him. His wife blamed the military for not counseling him.

A few women were in denial that it was actually their son that was killed.

Made in 2008, most people still hope, in a corner of their minds, that their son will come walking through that door.

I remember feeling that way when my own father died. I was 34 and he was 59. In the winter, he used to pick me up so I wouldn’t have to drive in the snow, but his phone call never came. I am not still waiting, however. After his death I did not laff for five years, such was my grief.

Today I love seeing fathers and daughters together. My own son, Dan, of course, with his Grace Catherine. And the neighbors with their children.

A question I often ask myself is, Is it possible to enjoy life when we live in such a troubled world?

 
     My comment: 
 
         A sensitive and provocative post, Ruthie.

         I believe that it is not only possible, but that it is imperative to enjoy life as much as possible in order to create sense and purpose out of the ongoing troubles and suffering we see and feel in this world.
         I also believe that it is this very suffering that opens up our consciousness and expands our compassion. We can transform our grief and pain and heal from it and when we travel through the journey mindfully, we can find the resiliance we need to meet the challenges of life. It’s not easy but our choice is to drown in the suffering we see and let it take us, or to grow from it and transform it in some way that is unique to each of us. 

    

AUTUMN YEARS DON’T LAST FOREVER

      When was the last time you called your mother or father and truly listened to what was going on in their lives, to their thoughts, beliefs and even to their worries?  This isn’t a guilt trip I am trying to lay on you.  Let’s hope you will take a look at a few things that might change your thinking a bit.

     Are your parents in their fifties or sixties, or even seventies?  Are you accustomed to thinking of them as forever young, vital and self-sufficient?  When everyone gets together for extended family functions, or when they attend a holiday party at your house, people are always saying how youthful they look.  Once a couple of years ago, your mother did you a favor and answered an urgent call of panic about something you forgot that you needed at work (Nobody else you called first was available) and she drove it to you.  Your colleagues thought she was your wife. 

     When your father proposes a game of touch football in the backyard on a beautiful fall day, he often outshines the younger bunch.  He also amazed all of your friends last month with his break dancing at your fortieth birthday bash.

     Your mother recently changed careers. She is a true Baby Boomer, always forging ahead and trying new things.  Perhaps she went back to school and got certified in a new field, or maybe she quit a job she was tired of and started a business.  She goes to the gym at least several times a week, is writing a novel and she is still the peace and justice advocate she was in her youth. She meditates and she plays Flamenco guitar with passion.

     Your father traveled to Haiti with his men’s group after the earthquake and serves at a local soup kitchen on his day off.  When your kids are bothered by something and you are too busy with your own job responsibilities, they call Grandpa to pour out their hearts to him.

     Mom is always coming up with unique dishes to accommodate your likes and dislikes, or making sure there is at least one interesting vegetarian dish on the table along with the rest of the traditional Thanksgiving fare.  She is also the one in the family who creates special occasions for a gathering of the clan,  despite being pretty busy herself.  She’s the one who remembers everyone with a  card, often an original creation and who finds the perfect birthday gift for you.  Her gifts are rarely commonplace and are always evidence that a lot of thought was put into them. 

     When you have a work crisis, even though you might not have called Mom or Dad for two months, you call them at 8 AM on a Saturday morning and chew their ears off about the latest conflict.  On your last call you were letting them know why you hadn’t been in touch much and how stressed you were.  They listened, as usual asked a few questions,  but mostly couldn’t get a word in edgewise.

     So when was the last time you phoned them for no reason whatsoever except to touch base and hear what is on their minds?  Has it occurred to you that just as you are worrying about the economy, about sending your kids to college, about your next career move, that your parents have worries of their own?  It’s pretty tough, if not nearly impossible for some to picture their vital and vibrant parents traveling from the autumn of their lives to the winter.  If you are very busy raising a young family or climbing the career ladder, you may not feel you even have the time to contemplate this.  Not only are your parents still young and invincible in your minds, but so are you. Time has a way of moving on, though, in spite of our sometimes frantic efforts to make it stand still.

     As you have witnessed when your parents stepped up to the plate and did whatever they could to care for and help your elderly grandparents, life brings changes. That is a given.  It’s part of the natural life cycle.  Most people do not remain healthy, young and capable forever.   So even if you cannot begin to imagine your parents aging to the point that they are no longer as active or as self-sufficient as they always were, it happens to the best of us.  Only a few truly fortunate ones maintain their ability to function intellectually, emotionally and physically as they did at younger stages of life.  Hopefully, your own parents will be an exception, but it’s a known fact that in the next  few years about tw0- thirds of Baby Boomers will be caring for an elderly parent or other relative.  Right now there are approximately 25 million caregivers for elderly relatives in the United States.  Over 80% of these are women and 70% are between the ages of 40-59.  The largest group of caregivers is concentrated within the Baby Boomer Generation, but there were about 76 million Americans born between the years of 1945-1964.  Eventually, a lot of those people are going to need the help and support of their children and other younger relatives.  Generations X and Y might want to do some thinking about this.

          It’s a known fact that with maturity comes a certain amount of wisdom.  The majority of us are not too interested in our family history, what our parents were like as kids and young adults, or even how our parents met and romanced each other. Many do not begin to see their parents as three-dimensional people, or to treat them with the compassion they might bestow on strangers, until they are fairly advanced in age themselves.   Such interest usually begins once we have seen enough of life to put a few things in perspective and often happens when we wake up and notice that our parents are really starting to age.  We then come face to face with both our parents’ mortality and our own.

     Now is truly an excellent time to stop the merry-go-round long enough to step down and have some crucial conversations with your mothers and fathers who are enjoying the autumns of their lives.  Can you commit to doing that soon?  In fact, I will put you on the spot and ask you WHEN?  Can you find a way to involve your kids in these important conversations and a way to create some fun and meaningful interactions for everyone, as well as a valuable life learning experience?

 

     Iris Arenson-Fuller, CPC is a Life Stage, Family, Relationship Changes Coach.   Think of Iris when you think of Big Life Changes, Hard Choices, Second Chances.

     Iris helps people  become become strong survivors and move from sorrow and stress to satisfaction and success.

     Iris specializes in working  with clients who have had losses, widows, widowers, Sandwich Generationers, and with loss issues related to the Adoption Community (Infertility, Adoptive Parents, Adoptees and Birthparents)  Iris  is a strong survivor herself and is a Loss to Light Expert. Contact her: iris@visionpoweredcoaching.com 

www.visionpoweredcoaching.com